China puts yuan within easier reach of Africa, but adoption faces major hurdles: report

Beijing eases yuan payments for African infrastructure projects, but debt, liquidity and regulatory barriers persist, analyst says.

China is making it easier for African countries to pay for Chinese-led infrastructure projects in yuan, but weak banking rules, high debt levels and historical dependence on the US dollar and euro continue to limit broader adoption of the currency, an Egypt-based political scientist said in an analysis released on Monday.
 
Beijing had been expanding its financial influence across Africa by integrating Standard Bank, the continent’s largest lender by assets, into China’s Cross-Border Interbank Payment System (CIPS), wrote Nadia Helmy, an associate political science professor at Beni Suef University in Egypt, on the digital media platform Modern Diplomacy.
 

CIPS, which Beijing promotes as an alternative to the Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication, commonly referred to as Swift, forms part of China’s broader effort to internationalise the yuan.

Expanding support for Chinese banking services overseas could facilitate payments for megaprojects in Africa through the Belt and Road Initiative, Helmy wrote. The initiative is Beijing’s 13-year-old programme to fund infrastructure development abroad.
 

Payments routed through CIPS could reduce foreign exchange conversion costs by as much as 4 per cent, Helmy said.

Several African countries already owe substantial debts to China, pushing them towards restructuring rather than expanding the adoption of new banking mechanisms

Nadia Helmy, Beni Suef University

Earlier this year, the People’s Bank of China authorised Standard Bank, in collaboration with Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, to operate as Africa’s yuan-clearing bank.

The move allows 19 African countries to make yuan-denominated payments without routing transactions through banks in New York or London.

However, Africa’s reliance on Western currencies, mounting sovereign debt pressures and a relative lack of strict banking regulations stood in the way of wider yuan adoption, Helmy said.

 

“Banking laws in Africa vary significantly from country to country and do not easily comply with the strict standards or restrictions imposed by China on capital flows,” she said.

Helmy also pointed to weaknesses in the region’s digital infrastructure.

“Modern Chinese settlement systems require a robust cybersecurity and communications infrastructure, which is not equally available across the continent,” she said. African financial markets also lacked sufficient yuan liquidity to support smooth daily transactions, Helmy added.

China pledged about US$51 billion in lending and investment for Africa at the 2024 Forum on China-Africa Cooperation.

But several African countries already owed substantial debts to China, Helmy wrote, “pushing them towards restructuring rather than expanding the adoption of new banking mechanisms”.

China views the continent as an important source of natural resources, while many African countries – including some of the world’s poorest – regard Chinese investment as a means to economic development.

According to United Nations and international development agency reports, at least 22 African countries were either in debt distress or at high risk of a sovereign debt crisis. High debt-to-gross domestic product ratios can undermine their ability to repay loans.
 
The terms of Chinese loans, which were “sometimes described as secret”, had also raised concerns about national sovereignty among African political elites and civil society, Helmy said.
 

“Attempts to integrate or adopt Chinese banking systems, such as the CIPS system or full reliance on the yuan, in Africa face several key challenges,” she said.